Category Archives: Books

The Chosen and the Beautiful, by Nghi Vo

The Great Gadsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald

This entry is a double header because The Chosen and the Beautiful is a rewrite of The Great Gadsby from the perspective of Jordan.

It has probably been 30 years since I last read Gadsby so I felt compelled to re-read it before starting Chosen. The rereading was helpful to fully appreciate Vo’s project of retelling the story from a female centric sex-positive and culturally diverse perspective. In retrospect I think I might have been better off reading Gadsby after Chosen so I could experience it fresh and not solely through the lens of the original.

Rereading Gadsby made me appreciate anew the original novel, and Fitzgerald’s beautiful prose. While The Chosen re-figured this foundational narrative of class and exclusion to cast a wider net of difference, it seemed somehow a weak gesture in comparison to the original.

Others I’ve spoken who didn’t try to read the Chosen relationally, seemed to enjoy it as an independent narrative. This reinforced for me the feeling that I might have done better rereading Gadsby after rather than before.

Accordingly I give The Chosen and the Beautiful 3.5👍 out of 5👍.

The Great Gadsby tests out of my rating scale.

Manhattan Beach, by Jennifer Egan

Jennifer Egan lives in Brooklyn, and one of the great pleasures of this book is the life she brings to its historic structures- the Navy Yard, the Coney Island Parachute Drop, the Red Hook Waterfront, the old houses of Clinton Hill.

This is all just the backdrop however for the inspiring story of Anna Kerrigan, a single woman in Brooklyn in the 1930’s who has the courage to investigate the mysterious disappearance of her father, and also pursue her dangerous dream of becoming a deep sea diver. Anna develops an informal network of women friends who help her overcome her challenges. Nell lends her a bike so she can run out during her lunch hour to watch the divers practice and get back to work on time. Rose invites her to stay with her family so she live closer to the Navy Yard and not tarnish her reputation by living alone. Her Aunt Brianna accompanies her across the country and helps her reinvent her life and care for her child.

Egan deeply researched the stories of Navy Yard workers and this shows in the specificity of the story- the weight of the diving suit, the different classes of married and unmarried working women, how families cared for special needs children. These details made this novel so captivating, and also inspiring.

I give Manhattan Beach 5👍 out of 5👍

The Future of Another Timeline, by Annalee Newitz

This feminist time travel novel will change your relationship to history and politics. Newitz’s description of going back in time to “edit the timeline” and change the future is a radical re-visioning of how small changes made by collective action can alter our future. A must read I give this book 5👍 out of 5👍.

Klara and the Sun, Kazuo Ishiguro

In Klara and the Sun, Ishiguro takes us on a compelling but very disorienting journey into the future. The story is narrated by an Artificial Friend – a sentient robot named Klara. Klara has the ability to learn and observe new things, and even reflect on them. But she is also limited in some mysterious ways by her construction. For example when presented with a new space, her mind grids off her field of view into 24 boxes, which seem to help her process new visual information. This is never explained to the reader; just as Klara is trying to decode the human world, the reader must decode the perceptions of Klara.

In this imaginary future America some event has occurred, which has divided our society into the “lifted” and the left behind. We hear humans talk in passing about the bewildering new caste system, but Klara rarely asks questions, or at least the questions we want her to ask.

What actually does it mean to be lifted? Is it a physical process? A medical procedure? A magical intervention? Or is it a more banal way of describing a large scale gifted and talented program? These questions nag at you throughout the book but remain unanswered.

In spite of this, or perhaps because of it, our attention is shifted to the characters’ relationships. Through our robot eyes however, interpersonal life is equally confusing. Is the AF a machine that you put in the trunk of the car, or a person who rides in the front seat? It seems the AF is something in between- not an equal member of the household – present and listening but standing in the corner. One keeps waiting for Klara to express resentment or anger at the inequality, but Klara seems to only exist to serve, and seems totally content with her life.

There are many other mysteries in this novel, but they are better read than explained. I give this book 4👍 out of 5👍.

The Watchmaker of Filigree Street by Natasha Pulley

This book starts as historical fiction and slides into magical realism so gently I questioned my browser as to what was real and what was not.

Set in Victorian London, the narrator, Thaniel Steepleton, is a telegraph clerk in the British Home Office who one day receives a bomb threat from Irish separatists. Returning home the night of the threat, he discovers an intricate gold pocket watch, which Thaniel is unable to open. The watch has no note or clue as to its origin. Then mysteriously on the morning of the impending Irish bomb, the watch suddenly clicks open. Thaniel is both intrigued and terrified when the watch suddenly emits a piercing alarm, which takes Thaniel away from the path of the bomb and saves his life.

Thaniel seeks out the watchmaker, and soon finds Keita Mori, a Japanese master craftsman with a love for making intricate mechanical creatures. A mechanical octopus attaches itself to Thaniel’s leg. Mechanical birds perch on the counter.

Mori’s magic with the mechanical is surpassed however by his ability to see the future. Mori casually mentions to Thaniel at the end of their first meeting that on his next date he should watch out for the waiter dropping his tray. Thaniel is ready when the waiter’s grip slips and avoids catastrophe.

Thaniel realizes that Mori’s uses his abilities to create elaborate ploys to change the future. An assassination plot is hatched by pouring liquid in the base of a tree he frequently passes, thus weakening its root system until one day it falls on an unsuspecting victim.

Watchmaker is full of elaborate constructions and intricate secrets and puzzles. But it also has moments of great tenderness and intimacy. I found this the most pleasurable book I’ve read in a long time and give it a 5👍 out of 5!

I am already on my third book by Natasha Pulley. All books contain the same mix of historical fiction and magic. Some of the characters, like Mori, make repeat appearances in the series. They all share this same sense of adventure and intrigue which is hard to put down!

Lost Children Archive, by Valeria Luiselli

Lost Children Archive is a many layered narrative, which kneads its layers together in unexpected ways. The primary story is a family road trip from New York to the Southwest. Although we never learn the names of the family members, we learn that both children came from previous marriages – the daughter to the mother (who narrates the first half of the book) and son (who narrates the second half) to the father.

The parents are both sound artists who met while working for the New York Urban Planning department, recording all the (600+) languages of New York. They fell in love, decided to merge their families and marry. When the New York project ended and they each began independent projects. He begins obsessively researching the native Apaches and Geronimo, and she (who we learn is from Mexico), starts working on deportation issues and immigrant children stuck at the border. Her project is prompted by a discussion with a friend whose two daughters had tried to cross in and were being held at the border. They decide to take a road trip with the family to visit the native American sites, and stop at the detention center on the way.

Interspersed with the road trip narrative are excerpts from “Lost Children Elegies”, a novel within a novel which tells of the arduous journey of seven children being smuggled into the US. The Elegies are numbered, and seem to be yet another of the many literary references which Luiselli weaves into her narrative. In fact this is just another story within the story that shifts from reference to narrative when the two unnamed children of the sound artists decide to slip out of the hotel because they think they know the location of the lost children and want to help their parents.

We follow the children on an epic journey through the desert and climbing aboard trains to get to the spot in the desert where they believe they will find the children. Although the reader is filled with an increasing sense of dread, they in fact connect with the children of the lost Children Elegies who jump off the page into the narrative.

Luiselli has in fact published a non-fiction account of her work as a translator for immigrant children, Tell Me How It Ends. The blurring of fact and fiction in Lost Children mirrors her own complex textual relationship to these issues. The book is not an easy read but provides a rich set of texts to help readers understand the challenges of the North American refugee crisis in a way both personal and political. I rate this book 4👍 out of 5👍.

Rhythm of War, by Brandon Sanderson

If you’re an epic fantasy buff like me you’ve probably dabbled in Brandon Sanderson. Actually at 1200 pages, dabbling is probably not the right word. Rhythm of War is Book 4 in the Stormlight Archive series. The plot is so complicated that I had to re-read book 3, Oathbringer, before I could figure out what was going on. It didn’t take long for me to get sucked into this world of special powers, conflict among indigenous and colonizing races, and parallel worlds (the Physical and Cognitive Realms). I know it’s not for everyone, but if you like this kind of thing, I give this a 4👍 out of 5👍.

Still Life, by Louise Penny

I was introduced to Louise Penny by Lisa from Oblong Books, whose recommendations are usually spot on. This is the first in a series of detective novels based in Canada, and featuring Agent Gamache. Lisa told me “the writing gets better as the series progresses” and I assume that is the case.

I enjoyed reading mystery in a new setting, but the narrative was a little clunky. I give this 2.5👍 out of 5👍.

The Vanishing Half, by Brit Bennett

Once I started reading this book I couldn’t put it down. At work I kept sneaking off to the bathroom so I could get in a few chapters after lunchtime.

The story is centered around the identical twins Stella and Desiree Vignes, who grow up in the town of Mallard outside of New Orleans. Mallard was “a town that, like any other, was more idea than place. The idea arrived to Alphonse Decuir in 1848, as he stood in the sugarcane fields he’d inherited from his father who’d once owned him. The father now dead, the now-freed son wished to build something on those acres of land that would last for centuries to come. A town for men like him, who would never be accepted as white but refused to be treated as Negroes. A third place.”

The interstitial “third place” which is the basis for the founding of Mallard, is expressed in the struggles the Vignes twins face when they run away to New Orleans at age 16. Away from Mallard, the girls see their light skin against the segregated societies of whites and blacks in New Orleans. In this new context they choose very different paths as one twin connects with her darker roots, while the other opts to blend in with the lighter.

Marriage in The Vanishing Half takes a bad rap – the most successful relationships are never formalized by marriage, but are makeshift and unconventional. The married couples are torn apart by some form of racial injustice; most dramatically the twins’ father who is brutally lynched and killed when they were younger, leaving their mother a widow and struggling in poverty. More generally all relationships in this book are marked by the influence of past traumas, and the girls’ witnessing of their father’s death effects both girls, although in different ways.

The Vanishing Half is very much of this time, and the compelling story allows us to look at complex relations of race and class through a slightly different lens. I give this book a 4.5 👍 out of 5 👍.